Sarah Creal Eyes Up Eyeliner Review: Is Copper the Standout Shade?
At 42, Insta has been pushing Sarah Creal Beauty hard on my feed. The brand is positioned for women 40+, and apparently the algorithm knows me well. A sucker for anything copper and light-catching around my eyes, I decided my first purchase would be the Sarah Creal Eyes Up 24H Creamy Kajal Longwear Eyeliner in Copper. I was a little skeptical, because "creamy" and "24 hour" don't usually belong in the same sentence, but I was very pleasantly surprised.
Sarah Creal is a veteran product developer, working with brands like Prada and Victoria Beckham Beauty, and that expertise shows in the formula. Unlike most longwear pencils that feel dry or are difficult to apply, this one glides on smoothly, stays hydrated at the lash line, and actually moves with your expressions without migrating. It is also comfortable enough for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, and I happen to be both!
Sarah Creal Eyes Up Eyeliner: The Performance Test
The product glides on easily without any tugging or crumbling. You have roughly 30 to 45 seconds to smudge, wing, or diffuse the line before it sets completely. Once it locks down, it is transfer-proof, smudge-proof, and waterproof.
I tested it through a full day of wear, including over a rich eye cream. Many high-end liners break down when they hit the dense oils in a potent eye treatment, but this one stayed put the entire day.
Does it Sharpen Easily?
Yes! I've had trouble sharpening similar eyeliners from other brands. Many are too creamy to sharpen back to much of a point. The Sarah Creal eyeliner sharpened easily in a standard sharpener from my beauty bag.
How Does It Compare to Victoria Beckham Beauty Satin Kajal?
Given that Sarah Creal developed products for Victoria Beckham Beauty, the comparison naturally comes up. Honestly, both deserve a place in your collection because they do different things.
The Victoria Beckham Satin Kajal is great for a blown-out smoky eye. It stays blendable and is designed for maximum diffusion. The tradeoff is precision. The formula is so rich and soft that sharp lines are difficult to achieve, and some smudging throughout the day is part of the deal.
The Sarah Creal liner offers a similarly luxurious glide on application but sets down faster and holds sharper. Once it locks in, it stays put.
To me it all comes down to the look you are going for. If you want effortless, smoky smudginess, Victoria Beckham is unmatched. If you want sharp precision and a smudge free finish, Sarah Creal is the one to reach for.
The Shade Spotlight: Is Copper Worth It?
While the Sarah Creal eyeliner range includes beautiful everyday shades like Jet Black and Rich Cocoa, Copper is the standout of the collection.
Traditional black or dark charcoal liners can read as harsh for daytime wear. Copper is a brilliant modern alternative. The warm base tone makes the eyes look instantly brighter and more awake.
The shimmer is not chunky or glittery. It is a finely milled metallic sheen that catches the light elegantly without drawing attention to any lid texture. Worn as a clean line or diffused into a soft wash of color, it adds a luminous warmth that a basic brown just cannot replicate.
Sarah Creal Eyeliner: Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Luxurious application: Glides on smoothly without skipping or tugging
- Genuinely longwear: Budge-proof and smudge-proof once set, even over rich eye creams
- Skin-supportive formula: Ceramides and allantoin keep the lash line looking hydrated, not parched
- Copper shade: A sophisticated, flattering alternative to basic black or dark brown for everyday wear
Cons/Considerations:
- Quick set time: You have 30 to 45 seconds to blend before it locks, so work fast
- Not for smoky eye lovers: If you want maximum blendability all day, the Victoria Beckham Satin Kajal is a better fit
The Final Verdict
A sucker for a copper moment, I will admit I was already rooting for this one. But even setting that aside, the Eyes Up Creamy Kajal genuinely delivers. It glides on without tugging, stays put through a full day of wear, and offers more precision than most Kajal eyeliners I have tried.
At 42, I definitely don't want formulas that settle into fine lines or migrate when applied over eye cream. This one does neither. The Copper shade in particular has become a regular in my rotation as it's brightening on my deep-set eyes, and brings out the gold flecks in my hazel eyes.
If you're looking for a beautiful, blendable Kajal that offers precision and a waterproof, smudge-proof experience, this is one to add to your collection!
